Woolworths, Honest to Goodness: Alleged Infringement On IP
Woolworths faces IP fight with small retailer
By Michelle Hammond
An independent food retailer will go up against supermarket giant Woolworths today over use of the phrase “honest to goodness” in its latest advertising campaign, arguing it infringes intellectual property.
Organic Marketing Australia, which trades as Honest to Goodness, alleges Woolworths’ latest marketing push – starring celebrity chef Margaret Fulton – infringes its intellectual property.
Based in NSW, the family-owned business was started by Matt Ward and his wife in their home eight years ago, and also trades as a wholesaler and online retailer with around 30 staff.
It’s believed Ward sent a letter to Woolworths objecting to use of the term “honest to goodness”, alleging it infringes on his company’s trademark.
Ward claims this was followed up by a letter from his solicitor, stating that while Woolworths acknowledged receipt of the letter, it had not officially responded.
Woolworths has denied the allegations, maintaining the term “honest to goodness” is a common phrase that can be used freely.
“The phrase ‘honest to goodness’ describes something which is essentially simple and genuine and, in the context of Margaret Fulton’s family meals, also nutritious,” a Woolworths spokesperson says.
“We will continue to work with the parties involved to resolve this matter.”
A spokesperson for IP Australia says Organic Marketing Australia has registered an ‘Honest to Goodness’ trademark and it is their choice as to how they manage it.
“They’ll choose whether to try to reach an outcome with Woolworths directly or whether the issue will be played out in the courts,” the spokesperson says.
“That’s not to say this is the case in this instance, but searching the trademarks database is an important step for all businesses looking to enter a market with a newly branded product or service,” he says.
Trademark lawyer James Omond says a trademark infringement only occurs if someone else uses the words as a trademark.
“If it’s a descriptive phrase and the second user can show that they’re actually only using it describe their goods or services, it’s not going to be a trademark infringement,” he says.
Omond says small businesses should also be wary of taking on corporate giants.
“If you’re coming up against the 800 pound gorilla, they might have deeper pockets than you. You might have a good legal case but you don’t have the wallet to see it through,” he says.
“And even if you do win, the cost orders that you get mean that you’re still a loser; it costs a lot of money… not to mention the huge stress that goes with that.”
Share This page :
FREE DOWNLOAD - 25 start-up ideas for 2011
LESANZ 2011 Annual Conference: Licensing Across Society
LESANZ 2011 Annual Conference: Licensing Across Society Licensing impacts almost all aspects of our daily lives. From entertainment to medicine, from what ...
Business Shorts - Servcorp Business Networking Melbourne
Servcorp Business Shorts provides an information evening and a local networking opportunity for like-minded business professionals in Melbourne....
Sydney Young Entrepreneurs Program
So where are some of our past FRANK participants @ now? •Listed as one of BRW‘s Fastest 100 growing companies – Husayn Aly •Anthill 30...
Ideas2Market Masterclass Workshop - Mt Isa
The Ideas2Market Masterclass workshop is designed for existing businesses that are looking to grow, improve and foster sustainability. This full day ...
Capital raising seminar
Considering raising equity?Do you have a sound business concept?Is your company growing/expanding?Is your business investment ready?Is your business investor...