Start-ups may begin (and end) their lives as small businesses, but by definition, they all plan to grow. While the federal government has announced a focus on simplifying red tape for business, rapidly growing early stage businesses have slightly different needs the government should be aware of. Australia is once again talking about the regulatory burden of doing business here after the leaked terms of reference for a Productivity Commission review into the Fair Work Act revealed the government’s priorities for lightening the load our entrepreneurs and job creators face. These include penalty and pay rates, and flexibility. While changes to these business fundamentals will touch the start-up community, there were two legislative hurdles brought up by every start-up founder and consultant StartupSmart spoke to for this story: employee share schemes and crowdsourced equity. Policies to boost the shortage of risk capital were also mentioned frequently. With two of these three issues under review, start-up founders say relief and increased productivity could come from alleviating some of the day-to-day burden of complicated tax systems that eat into time they could otherwise be investing in growing their companies. Site Tour founder Michael Scruby told StartupSmart the regulations around running a fast growing business are holding start-ups back. “The current regulations make it too onerous,” Scruby told StartupSmart. “There are lots of different areas you need to understand and comply with. As a founder, you’re working 70 hours a week but I’m spending at least half a day doing paperwork.” Scruby says if the government wanted to see small business grow and employ people, they should reconsider the quarterly business activity statement’s GST threshold. Businesses that are turning over $75,000 or more per year need to register, report and comply with GST regulations. While this may be manageable for sole traders and a drop in the ocean for big business, Scruby says it’s a low threshold for high investment businesses such as tech start-ups, which can be turning over $75,000 a year and still be nowhere near profitability. “Start-ups are stuck in between. For the first few years as you’re ploughing all the cash back into the business so this GST threshold makes running a business with limited resources onerous, expensive and just really tough,” he says. Tim Reed, the chief executive of accounting software and support company MYOB, told StartupSmart BAS was top of the list of concerns raised by their customers every year in the annual surveys. “It’s a cumbersome process even though we’ve been living with it for just on 14 years now,” Reed says. Not only is the regulation challenging to understand and time consuming to comply with, its implementation requires business owners to keep a lot of information for auditing processes. While many entrepreneurs, including Scruby, would like to see the threshold raised, Reed says this is a short-term fix that would only benefit whichever businesses fall beneath the new threshold. “If the government could go through and look at the regulation around the GST, they could take the big steps forward to make it simpler,” he says. “This would touch most small businesses and would have a very big impact. It would mean the time it takes to complete a BAS could be reduced by 50- 75%.” Reed also hears repeatedly from clients about unnecessarily complex and varying legislation such as award and penalty rates. He says simplifying both the award structure and nationalising the state-by-state system of occupational health and safety requirements would be a boost for rapidly growing start-ups. “We speak to a lot of businesses that could grow their business, turn over more and employ more people but they don’t want to deal with all the extra rules,” Reed says. Expanding into three states means dealing with three different OHS systems which means three times the paperwork, and triples the risk of staff getting hurt and businesses being fined. While the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) had agreed to unify the system just over five years ago, little progress has been made. All of these compliance hurdles require time and often expert consultants to help young businesses navigate the challenges. This adds to the costs and time it takes to get a start-up to profitability, which in turn raises the amount of investment funds needed. Raising funds could be made significantly easier with a few small regulatory changes, says DLA Piper senior associate and AngelCube accelerator legal mentor Joel Cox. “One of the most time-consuming regulations that could be fixed for early stage companies here is the restrictions and requirements for issuing new equity,” he told StartupSmart. Australian companies that are issuing new equity have to create a prospectus unless they meet criteria exempting them from this requirement. In his practice, Cox says the most common exemption for start-ups is for a small scale round. This limits the founders to making personal offers to fewer than 20 people for a total of less than $2 million. “With an increase in the number of angel funding rounds, we’re seeing more rounds with large numbers of participants,” Cox says. “But it’s not viable at all for an early stage company to produce a prospectus. This means they have to amend their fundraising round to fall within the restrictions, which are very confusing to understand and do require a lawyer and therefore legal fees many can’t afford.” Cox is hopeful the review into crowdsourced equity now underway may address this issue. The biggest issue for Cox wasn’t any particular piece of legislation or the impact it had on early stage businesses plotting global growth. “Australia is slow to adapt to the changes in the market around the growth and proliferation of early stage companies getting ready to grow quickly, as opposed to the US and Israel for example,” Cox says. Cox says updating the employee share scheme regulations and crowdsourced equity restrictions must be priorities for the federal government if they want to see the start-up ecosystem take off.
Small business leaders around Australia are concerned the appointment of Gary Gray as the sixth small business minister under the current government creates further uncertainty about the direction of small business policy in Australia. Given Gray has also been handed responsibility of the resources, energy and tourism portfolios, SME advocates believe he will not be able to adequately dedicate his time to understanding the needs of small business. Council of Small Businesses of Australia executive director Peter Strong told SmartCompany he’s disappointed by the rate of turnover in the position. “We run on confidence, but it’s hard to be confident when we’re unsure of the future. There have been a lot of surveys done and uncertainty is the biggest problem,” he says. “I don’t know how much he understands, we’ll have to see if he understands the issues facing small business about competition law and consumer problems.” “He needs to sit down and give the industry confidence and set some policies.” Prior to his position in government, Gray worked with companies such as BHP Steelworks, Wesfarmers and as an advisor to Woodside Petroleum. Strong says when it comes to the small business minister, background is important. “If you have a background like [Opposition Small Business Spokesman] Bruce Billson does in small business, then you are more likely to understand the problems businesses face.” Without that, Strong says it comes down to the attitude Gray has and if he has the capacity to understand the fact we’re not just business we’re people,” he says. SmartCompany contacted Gray for comment but received no response prior to publication. Australian Retailers Association executive director Russel Zimmerman told SmartCompany Gray won’t have the time to develop an understanding of small businesses prior to the September election. “It would be nice to see a person allocated the role stay in it long enough to be able to get to understand small businesses.” “It’s going to be hard for him to get a grasp on the portfolio. If they are returned again, we hope they’ll bring some stability,” he says. Zimmerman says an election needs to be held because the government has recently become a “farce”. “I think there was a good reason for the government to go to the people because it’s become a farce,” he says. Zimmerman says he’s also concerned with the number of responsibilities Gray is taking on board. “Tourism and small business go hand and hand, but certainly his other role will not be necessarily associated with small business,” he says. Gray is yet to communicate with Zimmerman or Strong, but both industry representatives say they hope he will do so soon. Accounting group MYOB released a new report today which found SME dissatisfaction with the federal government remains high at 54%. MYOB chief executive Tim Reed told SmartCompany the number of recent small business ministers is “appalling”. “It’s a message which says government policies have not been well explained to small business owners,” he says. This story first appeared on SmartCompany.
MYOB chief Tim Reed has joined the board of digital health platform Healthshare, which has announced the successful closing of its capital raising, although the amount is undisclosed.
MYOB has outlined seven steps start-ups should take to boost their business in 2013, after revealing more than half of small businesses hope to improve systems and processes this year.
The business outlook is brighter for SMEs in 2013, according to the latest MYOB research findings, but micro businesses will continue to do it tough and have been urged to plan ahead.
Online retailers will experience their highest volume of Christmas sales from December 7-10, according to a new survey, while sales for offline retailers will peak closer to Christmas Day.
More businesses have websites but fewer are actually using online tools, including search engines and social media, to market their products, according to the latest MYOB Business Monitor.
Compliance with government regulation continues to stifle business operations, according to a new report, which shows more than 80% of the businesses surveyed are struggling with red tape.
Almost one-fifth of entrepreneurs start their business as an investment strategy for the future, according to the latest MYOB research, while 18% start up because they want a seachange.
More than 40% of business owners say starting their own business made them “very proud”, new research reveals, but business milestones are outshone by personal achievements.
Almost half of Australian business operators borrowed money to stay afloat in the last 12 months, with just a quarter of them borrowing money to spend on their business, new MYOB research shows.
The carbon tax has been a contentious issue in the Australian business community since the Federal Government announced shortly after the last election that it will come into effect on July 1 this year.
Small business owners will be among the more nervous observers of today’s interest rate decision, with new research showing that more than a quarter of Australian SMEs use their mortgage to finance their business.
Start-ups are slightly more likely to have their own website than established small businesses, according to a new MYOB report, which shows 64% of Australian SMEs still don’t have their own online operation.
Small business owners have a worryingly poor knowledge of a number of regulatory changes set to start in the new financial year, such as amendments to superannuation and the tax-free threshold, according to new research.
The reputation of the Federal Labor Government among businesses continues to falter, new figures show, as Prime Minister Julia Gillard attempts to cuts her losses over the Craig Thomson and Peter Slipper controversies.
In an attempt to keep costs down, almost one-third of small business owners haven’t taken a holiday since they started their business, according to a new MYOB report.
A third of Australian business owners plan to increase activity in new markets in 2012, according to the latest MYOB report, although only 22% intend to increase their number of sales promotions.
Small business owners’ ire with the Federal Government has soared to a three-year high, according to a MYOB report, with more than half of Australian SMEs now dissatisfied.
MYOB and PayPal have launched a new initiative enabling small businesses to set up a website and begin accepting payments within an hour, in a bid to cash in on the growth of eCommerce.